10:P14
Commentary on the Athrabeth

More information on this P-text coming soon.

Volume: Morgoth’s Ring
Chapter: Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth
Pages: 329–349
Paragraph count: 96
Token count: 8,496

Citation Index

Page numbers refer to the setting used by all editions other than mass-market paperbacks.

p329
ATHRABETH FINROD AH
The Debate of
This is not
It is in
p329–330
There are certain
p330
With regard to
1. There exists
2. There are
3. Hröa and
p330–331
4. The separation
p331
5. Elvish ‘immortality’
6. From this
7. Since Men
The Elves observed
Beyond the ‘End
p332
Their dilemma was
Some argued that,
But they saw
Therefore in the
For these reasons
p333
As is seen
He therefore guesses
p333–334
Andreth says that
p334
More strictly speaking,
Finrod, however, sees
p334–335
Only Eru himself
p335
Since Finrod had
The argument is
p335–336
In the event
p336
Finrod thus was
Author’s Notes on
Note 1
Because fëar were
According to the
The Eldar held
The additions of
p336–337
Thus the ‘newness’
p337
Note 2
Arda, or ‘The
The traditions here
p337–338
It is certainly
p338
These views are
The Elves were
p338–339
But in any
p339
Note 3
In Elvish tradition
They were given
p339–340
They ‘normally remained
p340
Note 4
p340–341
Sooner or later:
p341
The passing ‘oversea’
Note 5
They were thus
Note 6
Because the Valar
p342
Note 7
See Note 2.
p342–343
We are here
p343
Note 8
Desire. The Elves
Note 9
p343–344
It is probable
p344
The ‘Tale of
Note 10
p344–345
‘Matter’ is not
p345
Note 11
This is actually
[‘The Tale of
Then Andreth being
Some say the
We understood the
p345–346
In that time
p346
But we were
Then one appeared
Then we looked
He was less
Therefore we revered
All that he
Then we spoke
p346–347
Then he went
p347
We fell upon
Then in fear
‘So be it!’
And when we
There were some,
Thereupon he went
Ever after we
The first Voice
p347–348
Then our terror
p348
‘Now ye are
Thereafter we were
Then we yearned
For most of
Then there arose
Then in fear
p348–349
But it is